Born Benjamin Franklin Peay in Camden, South Carolina in 1931, Brook Benton became a gospel singer at a young age. While still a child he worked delivering milk in the morning and joined the Camden Jubilee Singers.
He enjoyed writing songs and in 1948, at age 17, journeyed to New York City to try to sell some of them. With his gospel singing background, it was not long before he drifted in and out of gospel groups such as Bill Langford's Spiritual Singers, the Langfordaires, the Golden Gate Quartet, and the Jerusalem Stars. Brook returned to South Carolina and drove a truck for a while continuing his music career. He joined an R&B singing group, the Sandmen, and once again went north in search of a big break.
Brook found steady work making hundreds of demo records for such established singers as Nat "King" Cole, Clyde McPhatter, and Roy Hamilton. He co-wrote a number of songs with Clyde Otis. He first recorded under his own name for the Okeh label in 1953. Brook signed as a solo act with Epic and had his first minor hit with “A Million Miles From Nowhere” on Vic. He went on to Mercury along with Clyde Otis and arranger Belford Hendricks, and it was at Mercury that he would meet with his greatest success.
In 1959 he broke through with a two-sided hit, “It's Just A Matter Of Time”, backed by “Endlessly”. The former reached #1 on the RnB charts and the latter #3, and those were the first of 23 top forty hits that Brook Benton would record, either as a solo or a duet, from 1959 to 1964.
Brook had a certain warmth in his voice that attracted a wide variety of listeners. He sang ballads that led to comparisons between Brook and such established performers as Frank Sinatra, Nat Cole, and Tony Bennett. He had another top ten hit with “So Many Ways,” then was teamed with another emerging Mercury star, Dinah Washington. In 1960 this duo put two songs in the top ten, “Baby [You've Got What It Takes]” and “A Rockin' Good Way [To Mess Around And Fall In Love].”
In the early 60's the hits that he recorded kept coming. These included a string of top ten pop hits such as “Kiddio,” “The Boll Weevil Song,” and “Hotel Happiness.” He was prolific in issuing records that sold, one of which was “Shadrack.” “The Boll Weevil Song” was Brook's only successful novelty song, and his highest charting song ever as it held the number two slot for three weeks in the summer of 1961.
His string of successful hits began to slow down somewhat in about 1963, although he still managed to reach the top forty with records such as “I Got What I Wanted” and “Two Tickets To Paradise,” and “Going Going Gone” in 1964 for Mercury. The arrival of the Beatles marked a change in taste by the record buying public. Brook began to go from label to label, recording for RCA, Reprise and Cotillion.
Brook Benton remained popular as a performer, particularly in Great Britain, into the 80's. He died in New York City in 1988 of complications from spinal meningitis.